Consciousness and Cognition
○ Elsevier BV
Preprints posted in the last 90 days, ranked by how well they match Consciousness and Cognition's content profile, based on 19 papers previously published here. The average preprint has a 0.01% match score for this journal, so anything above that is already an above-average fit.
Dahech, H.; Minami, T.; Nakauchi, S.; Tamura, H.
Show abstract
Why does an angry face feel uncomfortable? The answer is that it signals a threat. However, a face is only part of an encounter, and distance, facial stimulus type, and gaze may shape discomfort regardless of perceived anger. To separate these cues, we conducted three within-subjects virtual reality experiments. In each experiment, 24 adults viewed avatars at intimate, personal, and social distances (30, 100, and 300 cm, respectively) and rated the faces perceived anger and their own discomfort; head movement was recorded in Experiments 2 and 3. In Experiment 1, the expression (angry, neutral) and facial color (natural, red) were crossed with distance; in Experiment 2, a featureless mannequin served as a nonface comparison; and in Experiment 3, the gaze direction (direct, averted) was manipulated. Expression primarily determined perceived anger, whereas distance predominantly determined discomfort: A nearby neutral face was uncomfortable despite low perceived anger (Experiment 1). A neutral human face was more uncomfortable than a mannequin, although both received similarly low perceived-anger ratings (Experiment 2). Direct gaze increased the discomfort without changing perceived anger (Experiment 3). Backward head movement exhibited a similar pattern, with participants leaning back more from human faces than from the mannequin. These results indicate that the discomfort associated with an angry face is not merely explained by perceived anger. Instead, social discomfort was differentially associated with interpersonal distance and gaze direction and differed between the human-face and mannequin conditions.
Chulet, M.; Hamilda, J.; Rani, J.; Margabandhu, K.; Prasad, T. K.; Bosco, C. J.; Sampathkumar, S.; Victoria, M. M.; Sunderraj, E. S.; Rafi, R.; Jepegnanam, R. T.; Ninan, G. A.; Selvaganesan, S.; Prabhakar, A. T.
Show abstract
Certain conscious contents--such as the covert name of a viewed object--arise involuntarily and resist suppression, a phenomenon captured by the Reflexive Imagery Task (RIT). Whether a subliminal prime can bias which of two simultaneously present objects captures such an involuntary naming response has not been established. We adapted a two-object RIT into a self-contained, browser-based instrument. Thirty-eight adults (M age = 21.6 years, SD = 2.3; 26 female) viewed 24 object pairs and were instructed to fixate a central cross, to refrain from thinking of the objects names, and to click an object whenever its name intruded into awareness. On each trial a masked prime (17 ms, flanked by pattern masks) was either the exact name of one object (Exact Word Prime), a semantic associate of one object (Semantic Prime), or a neutral string (No Prime), defining a primed side per trial. A post-experiment debriefing confirmed that participants noticed the masks but none consciously perceived or could identify the prime words, indicating that the primes were subliminal. Analyses excluded 91 of 912 trials (10.0%) with more than five clicks. The priming effect was robust across measures: an omnibus comparison of clicks across conditions was significant (Friedman {chi}{superscript 2}(2) = 6.59, p = .037); within both prime conditions participants clicked the primed side more than the not-primed side (Exact Word, p = .039; Semantic, p = .005); and the primed-to-not-primed ratio exceeded parity by roughly 57-59% (Laplace-smoothed ratio {approx} 1.58; one-sample Wilcoxon p < .001 for each). A Bayesian Poisson generalized linear mixed model with random participant intercepts confirmed a credible primed-side advantage (incidence rate ratio = 1.72, 95% credible interval [1.57, 1.90]) that did not differ between prime types. No general left/right response bias emerged. An exploratory ight-side x Exact Word Prime interaction was inconsistent across model classes and is reported as hypothesis-generating. The findings indicate that subliminal lexical and semantic primes can steer the spatial locus of involuntary object naming.
Carbone, J.; Barner, C.; Encica, L.; Born, J.; Diekelmann, S.; Czekalla, N.; Schroeder, A.; Mueller-Pinzler, L.; Krach, S.
Show abstract
Sleep supports the consolidation of newly acquired information, however its role in the formation of self-beliefs has not yet been examined. Here, we investigated whether sleep facilitates the retention, stabilization, revision and long-term maintenance of newly formed ability beliefs. Using a Sleep vs. Wake between-subjects design (N=54), participants completed the Learning Of Own Performance (LOOP) task, which allowed them to form new positive and negative ability self-beliefs based on mocked feedback at a first session, and to revise them when encountering contradictory feedback at a second session. Belief formation was followed by either a sleep or wake retention interval. Belief states were tested at four time points: immediately after belief formation, after the 12-h retention interval, following the revision phase and after three weeks. Participants successfully formed and revised self-beliefs using the LOOP task. Compared with wakefulness, sleep following belief formation did not affect belief retention across the 12-h interval, nor did it stabilize beliefs against their revision. However, after three weeks, participants who slept after belief formation showed a shift towards more positivity for the initially formed low ability self-beliefs. Contrary to our hypotheses, sleep did not enhance short-term retention or stabilization of newly formed self-beliefs. However, the more positively recalled ability self-belief associated with the initially low-performance condition suggest that sleep may facilitate a positive long-term shift.
Pandey, P.; Pethe, S. R.; Indrajeet, I.; Ray, S.
Show abstract
Introduction: Decision making for selecting an object or a course of action from possible alternatives largely depends on our perceptual ability modulated by attention. When multiple stimuli appear close together in time, processing one stimulus can temporarily impair the processing of another due to temporal limitations of attention. Observers frequently fail to detect the second target (T2) presented within a few hundred milliseconds after the first target (T1) in a stream of stimuli, which is commonly known as attentional blink (AB). Existing theories attribute this perceptual lapse to T1 processing, distractor interference, or transient attentional gating; however, the computations underlying suppressive mechanism remains unresolved. We investigated whether pupil-size could reveal the underlying mechanisms of AB and predict conscious perception on a trial-by-trial basis. Methods: Pupil diameter and gaze locations were recorded using an infrared eye tracker. Machine learning techniques were used to classify trials when T2 was detected versus when it was not, after correct identification of T1, during an AB task from the pupil dynamics, which also yielded attentional episode (AE) associated with each element in the stream of visual stimuli when deconvolved. Results: Cross-validating classifiers achieved near-perfect accuracy not only in distinguishing but also predicting perceptual outcomes on a single-trial basis. AEs exhibited greater power when T2 was detected than when it was missed; the differential power in AEs on a logarithmic scale was highly synced with the differential pupil size. Conclusions: Collectively, these findings establish a framework for predicting attention-driven perceptual outcomes from pupil-dynamics at finer time-scale.
Klarlund, M.; Hua, S.; Vuust, P.; Du, Y.; Stupacher, J.
Show abstract
Social bonds are essential for well-being, and moving together to music is a universal means of promoting prosocial behavior and positive affect. However, the functions and interpretations of movement synchrony and music can vary across cultures and may depend on personal values. We examined how interpersonal synchrony and music affect social bonding in participants from individualistic (Denmark, N = 137) and collectivistic (China, N = 226) cultures. Participants watched videos of virtual stick figures - representing themselves (virtual-self) and an unknown person (virtual-other) - moving either synchronously or asynchronously to music or a metronome. After each video, participants rated three indicators of social bonding: their momentary feeling of social connectedness with the virtual-other (Inclusion of Other in the Self, IOS), likeability of the virtual-other, and well-being as the virtual-self. Personal values were measured using the Portrait Value Questionnaire. Music and synchrony promoted all three indicators of social bonding in both cultures, whereas cultural differences emerged in asynchronous conditions. Chinese participants rated the asynchronous virtual-other more likeable than Danish participants, aligning with the collectivistic emphasis on social harmony. Moreover, Chinese participants rated their own well-being higher than Danish participants when the virtual-self moved asynchronously, suggesting greater self-forgiveness in maintaining group harmony. The personal values of benevolence, conformity, and universalism interacted with movement synchrony and cultural background, underscoring the important role of values in interpretations of social interactions. Our findings highlight the universal prosocial effects of music and movement synchrony, while also emphasizing cultural nuances in how these effects are experienced.
Fiehler, K.; Oliveri, R.; Yanina E., T. G.
Show abstract
Brands increasingly express their positions on social issues through advertising, social media, and public campaigns. How such messages shape consumer perception is an ongoing area of investigation. Addressing a gap in brand activism research in marketing, this study uses eye- tracking technology to examine its impact on brand attitude, eye movement behavior, and memory retention. We tested these variables across three experimental tasks: an online survey, a free- viewing task, and a surprise memory recognition test. As a result, disagreement increased reading time for text statements, while agreement increased visual engagement (fixations) with the depicted product. Positive brand attitude also enhanced memory recognition for advertisements. Overall, disagreement appears to trigger effortful processing of conflicting information, while agreement facilitates visual absorption and strengthens product recognition. These findings highlight the cognitive risks and rewards of brand activism and provide a foundation for future research on its underlying perceptual and cognitive mechanisms.
Sakuragi, M.; Shinagawa, K.; Terasawa, Y.; Tanaka, Y.; Umeda, S.
Show abstract
Spontaneous thought changes over time, yet the moment-to-moment factors shaping these changes remain poorly understood. We examined whether heartbeat-related bodily processing, operating largely outside explicit awareness, is associated with the organization of ongoing thought. Forty adults performed an auditory attention task with intermittent thought probes in which auditory events were scheduled either 200 ms after each detected R peak (synch condition) or independently of ongoing cardiac timing (asynch condition), with occasional omissions in both conditions. Heartbeat-synchronous omissions in this paradigm have been shown to induce cardiac deceleration and modulate heartbeat-evoked potentials (HEPs). The score of the heartbeat counting task (HCT) served as a behavioral index related to cardiac interoceptive accuracy. The results showed that higher HCT score was associated with a stronger synch-asynch shift toward more self-related and less task/self-unrelated thought. HEPs showed a synch-related negative shift across several thought groups, although the magnitude of this condition effect did not reliably differ among thought groups. Overall thought-group distributions were similar across conditions, while transition analyses suggested a tendency in the synch condition toward more frequent transitions linking predominantly interoceptive stimulus-dependent thought with both on-task and self-related thought. Together, these findings suggest that heartbeat-related bodily processing may influence the organization of spontaneous thought, particularly in individuals with greater cardiac interoceptive accuracy. Bodily signals may therefore act as an automatic constraint on the ongoing stream of thought, biasing which thought contents and transitions become more likely over time.
White, D.; Varela, V. P. L.; Piggott, M.; Dunn, J. D.; Miellet, S.; Towler, A.; Popovic, B.
Show abstract
Recognising people precedes and informs most social interactions, yet it is not clear why individuals differ so markedly in face recognition ability. Exposure-based accounts propose that it is shaped by visual experience with faces, known as 'face diet', but most prior work treats exposure as passively acquired, thereby masking the active and dynamic nature of visual attention in natural settings. Here we examined whether spontaneous attention to faces in everyday environments predicts face recognition ability. Eighty participants wore mobile eye-tracking glasses while walking through a busy university campus and during a face-to-face interaction, before completing standard measures of face recognition ability. Fixations directed to faces showed stable individual differences in both settings. People who looked more at faces scored higher on our composite measure of face recognition ability, and gaze in the two settings predicted ability independently, together accounting for 22% of its variance. These findings suggest that differences in how people actively sample visual information from their environments may be an overlooked source of variance in perceptual expertise.
Hsiao, P.-Y. A.; Chou, F.-C. B.; Chen, P.-H. A.
Show abstract
When people watch the same political narrative, they often form different interpretations. Although prior research has shown that political ideology can shape shared neural responses to sociopolitical content, less is known about how individual differences in national identity ideology are associated with inter-individual similarity in neural dynamics during naturalistic viewing, particularly in sociopolitical contexts where national identity is highly salient in public discourse. We addressed this question across two studies in Taiwan by examining how Greater Chinese ideology relates to positive engagement and neural dynamics during naturalistic viewing of a pro-China video. In Study 1 (N = 52), higher Greater Chinese ideology was associated with greater positive engagement. In Study 2 (N = 60), participants underwent fMRI while viewing the same video. Intersubject representational similarity analysis showed that inter-individual similarity in Greater Chinese ideology was associated with inter-individual similarity in neural dynamics within the frontoparietal control network and default mode network. Notably, neural similarity was primarily observed among participants lower in Greater Chinese ideology, revealing an asymmetric pattern across the ideological continuum. These findings extend prior work on political ideology by demonstrating that national identity ideology is linked to both subjective experience and shared neural dynamics during political narrative processing in a non-Western context. HighlightsO_LINational identity ideology was linked to positive narrative engagement C_LIO_LIIdeology similarity mapped onto neural similarity in the FPN and DMN C_LIO_LIExperience and neural dynamics varied with national identity ideology C_LI
Sharifi Nowghabi, A.; Sharghilavan, S.; Bagheri, A.; Izadifar, M.
Show abstract
Wayfinding in hospitals is often hindered by ineffective signage; however, the cognitive mechanisms of healthcare wayfinding symbols comprehension remain under-researched. This study utilized eye-tracking and spatial gaze mapping to examine how visual complexity, abstraction, and human figuration modulate perception in 40 healthy adults viewing 24 hospital-related healthcare wayfinding symbols. Results indicate that pupil size is a sensitive physiological marker of cognitive load, significantly influenced by visual complexity ({chi}2 = 11.32, p = .022) and abstraction ({chi}2 = 7.49, p = .027). Human figuration reduced fixation duration and increased saccade amplitude, facilitating efficient semantic integration. Furthermore, human-centric healthcare wayfinding symbols elicited streamlined gaze trajectories, whereas abstract/complex designs induced chaotic scanpaths. These findings suggest that human figuration acts as a cognitive scaffold, reducing mental effort. We provide evidence-based guidelines for optimizing healthcare wayfinding symbols by prioritizing human body representations and balancing abstraction levels. HighlightO_LIPupil size indexes cognitive load during symbol comprehension. C_LIO_LIHuman figuration cuts fixation duration, boosting wayfinding efficiency. C_LIO_LIAbstract symbols increase pupil dilation, raising cognitive load. C_LI
Ishaq, A. N.; Goddard, E.
Show abstract
Attentional selection not only increases behavioural performance and neural information for attended stimuli but, in some instances, induces changes in stimulus appearance. While reported appearance changes have mostly concerned the effects of attending to a particular spatial location, here we report a shift in appearance that occurs when attention is directed to one component of a stimulus rapidly alternating at a single spatial location. Our stimuli included two frames of different colors, which alternated at 3.75Hz or 7.5Hz. Participants reported the perceived dominance of one frame's color in the reference stimulus, by comparison with a target stimulus. We found that when one stimulus frame was more salient than the other, with a greater likelihood of capturing exogenous attention, there was an illusory perception that the frame was physically present for a greater proportion of time. When the frames were matched in salience, a task encouraging participants to endogenously direct their attention to one frame produced a smaller shift in appearance. Our results add to the body of literature demonstrating that attention can change appearance, in this case altering the appearance of attended versus unattended stimuli that are presented at the same spatial location. Furthermore, our results demonstrate that at the 'temporal transparent' alternation rate of 7.5Hz, where rapidly alternating stimuli are perceived as two translucent surfaces, attentional selection of one surface can account for the apparent paradox that feature conjunctions are perceived at stimulus alternation rates higher than predicted by the temporal limits of feature binding for other stimuli.
Marcus, T.; Ross, D.; Kolluru, R.; Deen, B.
Show abstract
Understanding other people relies on long-term memory: we use learned information about others' personalities, mental states, and personal histories to make inferences about the causes of their behavior. However, little is known about individual differences in memory for high-level social information. Here, we develop and psychometrically evaluate a behavioral measure of social memory from narrative video content. Participants (N = 103) watched the pilot episode of the TV show Friday Night Lights, and answered multiple choice questions about characters' actions, statements, inferred mental states, relationships, and personalities immediately after viewing and following a 21-day delay. The social memory task showed moderate split-half reliability, demonstrating feasibility as an individual difference measure. Memory for information about specific events in the narrative showed a decline across the delay, while memory for abstract information remained stable. Social memory performance was correlated with separate measures of face-name association and verbal episodic memory, but not with face image recognition memory. These results provide a proof of concept for a novel behavioral measure of social memory and suggest that the measure relates to episodic and relational memory but not image recognition.
Parvizifard, O.; Parvizifard, A.; Forughi, A.; Heidari, M. M.
Show abstract
Objective: Mindfulness is a robust predictor of mental health, yet the psychometric properties of the short-form Five Facet Mindfulness Questionnaire (FFMQ-15) have not been examined in Iranian populations. This study evaluated the psychometric properties, factor structure, and diagnostic utility of the FFMQ-15 among medical sciences students. Participants: A total of 348 students (178 females, 170 males) from Kermanshah University of Medical Sciences participated. Methods: Participants completed the FFMQ-15, Penn State Worry Questionnaire (PSWQ), Difficulties in Emotion Regulation Scale (DERS), and Emotion Regulation Questionnaire (ERQ). Data were analyzed using exploratory and confirmatory factor analyses, composite reliability, and ROC curve analysis. Results: Both EFA and CFA supported the five-factor model, revealing a culturally unique item loading pattern. The FFMQ-15 demonstrated strong convergent and discriminant validity. ROC analysis indicated acceptable diagnostic accuracy for distinguishing high- and low-worry groups (AUC = 0.72, 95% CI: 0.66-0.78). Conclusions: The FFMQ-15 demonstrated acceptable psychometric properties in Iranian medical students. The non-reactivity facet exhibited cultural variability, suggesting that cross-cultural adaptation is essential. The instrument shows promise for screening in high-stress educational settings.
Bates, C. M.; Lingawi, L.; Perry, E.; Gallagher, M.; Martin, A. K.
Show abstract
The vestibular system has been implicated in several aspects of self-representation, including bodily self-location, yet its role in episodic source and reality monitoring remains unclear. Moreover, symptoms of depersonalisation and derealisation (DPDR) have been associated with both vestibular dysfunction and altered source and reality monitoring. We tested whether noisy galvanic vestibular stimulation (nGVS) modulates source and reality monitoring during a word-encoding paradigm and whether this increased symptoms of DPDR. Sixty young adults (N = 30 active nGVS, N = 30 sham) encoded words that varied by context (spoken vs. imagined), agentic source (self vs. other), and valence (positive vs. threat) before completing source/reality judgments. Active nGVS reduced overall accuracy relative to sham on both reality and source monitoring. Across conditions, self-referential items were remembered with greater sensitivity compared to other-referential items, and spoken items were recalled with greater sensitivity than imagined items. We additionally show an interaction effect whereby active nGVS reduced accuracy specifically for imagined and threat-valenced items. Trait DPDR did not moderate the effects of stimulation, although higher trait DPDR was associated with a more liberal reality-monitoring response criterion. Results indicate that transient vestibular perturbation via nGVS can impair source monitoring for internalised and threatening stimuli and impairs cognitive distinctions between internally and externally generated events in general, supporting a role for vestibular input in maintaining self-other and reality boundaries in episodic memory.
Lewis-Healey, E.; Kringelbach, M. L.; Canales-Johnson, A.; Laukkonen, R.
Show abstract
Effortful cognition is typically associated with controlled, task-constrained neural processing, whereas effortless awareness may require a more flexible, internally driven mode of brain organization. Critical brain dynamics provide a principled framework for characterizing this shift, as systems near criticality are thought to balance stability and flexibility, allowing efficient information processing without excessive control. Transcendental Meditation (TM), characterized by a shift from effortful mental engagement to effortless awareness, offers a natural model for testing this possibility. Here, we investigated whether critical brain dynamics track TM as a global meditative state, or instead reflect moment-to-moment fluctuations in subjective effortlessness. We combined high-density electroencephalography (EEG) with time-resolved phenomenological reports using Temporal Experience Tracing (TET). Experienced TM practitioners (N = 33) and matched controls (N = 33) completed resting-state recordings before and after a 30-minute TM or silent counting control task. Long-range temporal correlations (LRTCs) were quantified using detrended fluctuation analysis, while functional excitation/inhibition (fEI) balance was used to estimate directional deviations from criticality. State-based analyses showed that TM increased alpha and beta LRTCs relative to pre- and post-resting state within meditators, but revealed no robust between-group differences in either LRTCs or fEI balance. In contrast, neurophenomenological analyses showed that subjective effortlessness was robustly associated with increased theta, alpha, beta, and broadband LRTCs, with significantly stronger relationships in meditators than controls. Restricting analyses to low-effort periods further revealed higher beta LRTCs in meditators, a difference missed by conventional state comparisons. These findings identify scale-free neural dynamics as a candidate marker of "letting go" during meditation.
Arnau, S.; Plachti, A.; Alyan, E.; Wascher, E.; Schneider, D.
Show abstract
Spontaneous eye blinks have long been linked to cognitive processing, yet how task demands shape blink timing and its relationship to behavioral performance remains unclear. We examined spontaneous blink behavior in 576 adults performing two variants of the Continuous Performance Task (CPT). Blink occurrence and timing were most strongly modulated by the experimental condition in the more demanding CPT-AX task, whereas their association with response time was stronger in the CPT-X task, where more consistent blink timing predicted faster responses. This dissociation suggests that task structure changes not only blink behavior but also the behavioral relevance of blink timing. These findings are consistent with an adaptive scheduling account of spontaneous blinking and provide a conceptual framework for understanding when and why blink timing contains chronometric information about ongoing cognition.
Liu, T.-L.; Street, M.; Chao, Z. C.
Show abstract
Creative performance fluctuates from moment to moment, suggesting that it depends partly on transient internal states present before creative thinking begins. Although such fluctuations have been identified in central neural activity, it remains unclear whether they are also reflected in autonomic physiology. We examined whether cardiac and electrodermal activity during a brief pre-trial resting period was associated with subsequent creative performance. Photoplethysmography, electrocardiography, and electrodermal activity were recorded while 28 participants completed the Alternative Uses Test and Fusion Innovation Test, assessing divergent and convergent creative thinking, respectively. Data from 27 participants was included in the analyses. Heart rate, heart rate variability, tonic skin conductance level, and phasic skin conductance activity were extracted from observation windows ranging from 11 to 30 s within a 30-s pre-trial rest period. Trial-level creativity was evaluated using GPT-based ratings of novelty, feasibility, and goal attainment. Linear mixed-effects models showed that higher pre-trial tonic skin conductance level was consistently associated with better subsequent creative performance across tasks, with overall model fit peaking at a 21-s observation window. Permutation-based feature-importance analysis provided convergent support for the contribution of tonic skin conductance, whereas the cardiac and phasic electrodermal indicators showed no reliable independent associations. However, the model explained only a small proportion of behavioral variance. These findings suggest that tonic sympathetic arousal reflects a momentary physiological state associated with creativity potential, while autonomic signals alone remain insufficient for accurate individual-level prediction.
Hosseini, M.; Zivony, A.; Eimer, M.; Wyble, B.; Bowman, H.
Show abstract
Resolving the binding problem, i.e., how we integrate perceptual features in space and time to perceive objects, people and events as coherent wholes instead of masses of free-floating features, has been a central goal of cognitive scientists for decades. Conjunction errors occur whenever features are mis-bound leading to illusory percepts that were not actually presented. A specific kind of Rapid Serial Visual Presentation experiment induces temporal illusory conjunctions, called distractor intrusion errors. Despite these errors being well-established, current theories and models provide limited explanations. We present the 2-feature Simultaneous Type/Serial Token (2f-ST2) Model, the latest addition to the family of ST2-models, which simulates the most important behavioural and electrophysiological distractor intrusion findings. These include response distributions, reaction time patterns, and evoked electrophysiology responses. Importantly, we simulate these results across diverse empirical paradigms, implementing a range of stimulus sets, temporal dynamics, and involving multiple responses after each trial, without needing to modify our model's architecture or core parameters. Our findings are discussed in relation to theories of selective attention and working-memory binding. We argue that the 2f-ST2 model is more parsimonious than the leading theory of distractor-intrusions (the focussed-attention/sophisticated-guessing model), since it uses only a single binding mechanism, implying that correct bindings are simply fortunate conjunctions. The 2f-ST2 model further makes predictions for stimulus-competition, subjective-visibility and human electrophysiology. In summary, the ST2-model is a general framework for understanding how perception, temporal attention and working-memory interact, and the 2f-ST2 model extends the framework to distractor intrusions, thus explaining temporal feature binding.
Sun, C.; Zhou, R.; Zhang, D.; Wang, J.; Meng, Y.; Tang, R.
Show abstract
Consensus is rarely a one-off achievement. In a changing world, groups must repeatedly update judgments they have already agreed upon, making consensus updating a common feature of real-world collective decisions. However, previous research on collective decision-making has focused mainly on how groups reach a single consensus, leaving the updating of established consensus largely unexamined. This raises two unanswered questions: does consensus updating involve biases analogous to sunk cost, and are such biases related to the cost of the previous consensus? Building a Fake Consensus paradigm, we manipulated consensus-formation cost and examined how dyads updated a subjectively established consensus after new information arrived. An independent individual experiment provided information-matched updating baselines, allowing us to determine whether dyads updated less or more than individuals responding to the same evidence. Contrary to sunk-cost predictions, low-cost consensus led dyads to update less than the individual baseline, whereas medium- and high-cost consensus led them to update more. The pathway through perceived consensus sharedness was significant, and the association between sharedness and updating was stronger at higher left temporoparietal junction inter-brain synchrony. These findings indicate that the history of consensus formation shapes subsequent updating by altering the psychological meaning of shared endorsement, while interpersonal alignment determines how this shared experience translates into coordinated behavior. To our knowledge, this is the first experimentally controlled study of consensus updating in teams to isolate formation history from actual disagreement, providing a new paradigm for studying how collective judgments change after agreement.
Lin, C.-H. S.; Terence, N.; Garrido, M.
Show abstract
Bayesian decision theory proposes that people make statistically rational decisions by combining prior knowledge with sensory information (likelihoods). This framework successfully explains many aspects of human behaviour. However, debate persists over whether people perform precise Bayesian computations (i.e., explicit Bayesian strategy) or rely on less demanding strategies - such as approximations or heuristics - that produce Bayesian-like behaviour (i.e., implicit Bayesian strategy). To address this, we examined people's sensitivity to metamers: different prior-likelihood combinations yielding identical optimal policies. An explicit Bayesian observer would show a temporary performance drop immediately after a switch of prior-likelihood combination, followed by recovery, reflecting prior updating. In two studies, we trained participants to estimate hidden target locations drawn from a Gaussian prior. On each trial, scattered dots provided likelihood information. Over time, participants learned the prior and combined it with likelihood information to infer target locations. We then covertly introduced an untrained prior-likelihood metamer. Unlike explicit Bayesian observers, participants' performance declined after the switch and persisted throughout the untrained pair presentation. This finding challenges strict Bayesian interpretations of task performance and suggests that participants rely instead on likelihood-sensitive strategy that is neither explicit Bayesian nor does it not fully integrate prior information. Our study demonstrates how metamer manipulations can distinguish behaviour that merely appears Bayesian, from behaviour genuinely produced by Bayesian computations, and calls for the use of metamers for ruling out alternative explanations of Bayesian-like behaviours.